Episodes

Supernatural: What if… John Died in the Nursery Fire?

Rejoice! Taekia and Leah have come up with another fun format for the hellatus, and it’s the first in our soon to be beloved What If series. Let’s start with the beginning: what if it was John, not Mary, who died in the nursery fire. Would Mary have found Yellow Eyes quicker? Would Dean have to give up his soul for Sam? Would Sammy still go to Stanford? Come play with us in this weird and wild space!

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Jaanelle Yee, and driven by big nerd energy.

Supernatural Episode Sommelier: Family Dramas

We’re having more fun with format and are acting as your very own Supernatural sommeliers. Perhaps you want to indoctrinate a friend but they’re not into “monster shows,” or you’re in a  specific mood and can’t decide which episode to watch. Have no fear because today Taeki and Leah sharing our top 10 episodes for family drama feelings, and to prove our prowess we invite guest Sierra, who has never watched an episode, to share her feelings on “Lebanon.”

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Jaanelle Yee, and driven by big nerd energy.

Supernatural Commentary Track: The Real Ghostbusters

It’s our first week of experimental podcasting, since Supernatural has deigned to take a holiday from releasing new episodes. Join Taekia and Leah for their first ever episode commentary as they take on a season 5 classic (you know. Before Chuck was the worst.) They’ll talk real conventions vs this TV one, develop a drinking game on the spot, and pretty much continuously quote the episode along with the episode. Hey – we did warn it was experimental.

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Leah Cornish, and driven by big nerd energy.

His Dark Materials S1 E7: The Bear Place

We finally get to the fight between Iofur and Iorek, and we’re wondering why it was so underwhelming. There are some big revelations in this episode, but the mishandling of some key plot points is worrying. Join us to discuss season 1, episode 7 of His Dark Materials: The Fight to the Death.

This episode IS SPOILER SAFE. We will let you know before we go into spoilers so you can turn it off. If you are only watching the series, you’re fine to listen.

In this show: we go over every detail of the episode with our Dust Bears and Dust Bunnies. We also give out an Extra Award, perform our alethiometer readings!

Have some merch! We have a whole new Jordan College shirt!

Send us an email or a voice message with your theories about the TV show: extraneouspod@gmail.com. Also follow us on Twitter and Instagram, and join our Facebook group for even more HDM discussion goodness!

Remember to rate/review/etc! Also make sure to check out the His Dark Materials Mixtape!

Produced by Jaanelle Yee // hosts Melissa Anelli and William Redden

Supernatural S15E8: Our Father Who Aren’t In Heaven

As we stare headlong into out first month long hellatus, Leah and guest host Emilee (@ourshieldmaiden), take on the impressively packed and grammatically incorrect Our God Who Aren’t in Heaven. They talk the episode’s BIG return along with the OTHER big return. Y’all it was a really intense 42 minutes.

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Jaanelle Yee, and driven by big nerd energy.

Supernatural S15E7: Last Call

Making their way the only way they know how, Taekia and Leah are back again to riff on the latest episode of Supernatural. Press play to hear all about Taekia’s undying love for Christian Kane, alongside plenty of cooing as they discuss Sam/Eileen potential and Cas’ unfortunate timing.

This episode was sponsored by Shaker and Spoon; sign up now for $20 off your first box at shakerandspoon.com/extraneous

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Jaanelle Yee, and driven by big nerd energy.

His Dark Materials, S1 E5: Lost Daemons

WE HAVE SOME CONCERNS. We still love this show but are very concerned at the portrayals of daemon on the show and how it will play out. Episode five of the His Dark Materials series brings us to some real questions about how to best portray this amazing series on screen. Also: We meet Will!

This episode IS SPOILER SAFE. We will let you know before we go into spoilers so you can turn it off. If you are only watching the series, you’re fine to listen.

In this show: we go over every detail of the episode with our Dust Bears and Dust Bunnies. We also give out an Extra Award, perform our alethiometer readings, and add three more songs to the mixtape! Melissa brought a banger AGAIN. That’s twice in a rowl

This episode is sponsored by Tavour! ALSO! Have some merch!

Send us an email or a voice message with your theories about the TV show: extraneouspod@gmail.com. Also follow us on Twitter and Instagram, and join our Facebook group for even more HDM discussion goodness!

Remember to rate/review/etc! Also make sure to check out the His Dark Materials Mixtape!

Produced by Jaanelle Yee // hosts Melissa Anelli and William Redden

Supernatural Bonus Episode: Sorting the Winchesters

There was no new Supernatural this past week, so Taekia and Leah take this opportunity to dig a little deeper into the family Winchester… by sorting them into their proper Hogwarts houses! Basically if you’re looking for the “most extra” of the week, it’s us. Without question.

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Jaanelle Yee, and driven by big nerd energy.

Supernatural S15E6: Golden Time

Taekia and Leah spend at least 50% of this episode gushing over Eileen and to be perfectly frank, they’re not sorry. The most recent episode of Supernatural felt like a gift, and while they don’t trust Chuck, or the writers, they certainly won’t be taking it for granted. So press play to join the Eileen Leahy Appreciation Club – new members always welcome.

Stay hyped for the final season by checking out our always updated playlist on Spotify: [Extraneous] Supernatural Our Favorite Songs

SPOILER ALERT: This is a spoiler-filled podcast. If you want to follow along, watch Supernatural! We promise it’s great. 

This podcast is a part of the Mischief Media network. Follow us on Twitter @extraneouspod and Instagram @extraneous.pod and let us know all of your thoughts and feelings! This episode was edited by Leah Cornish, and is driven by big nerd energy.

His Dark Materials: S1 E3: Gyptians! Gyptians! Gyptians!

Extraneous is here to walk you through episode three of the His Dark Materials series! We spend most of this episode with the Gyptians. It’s emotional. There are emotions. EMOTIONS ARE HIGH!

This episode IS SPOILER SAFE. We will let you know before we go into spoilers so you can turn it off. If you are only watching the series, you’re fine to listen.

In this episode: we go over every  detail of the episode with our Dust Bears and Dust Bunnies. We also dig into daemonology, give out an Extra Award, perform our alethiometer readings, and add two more songs to the mixtape!

This episode is sponsored by our friends Tab for a Cause! ALSO! Have some merch!

Send us an email or a voice message with your theories about the TV show: extraneouspod@gmail.com. Also follow us on Twitter and Instagram, and join our Facebook group for even more HDM discussion goodness!

Remember to rate/review/etc! Also make sure to check out the His Dark Materials Mixtape!

Produced by Jaanelle Yee // hosts Melissa Anelli and William Redden